Should english be the national language

We wear the masks we think other people want to see While Ebonics might be a perfectly intelligible form of English to those who speak it, it goes against the grain of a white-dominated society in which belonging means talking the talk of Standard English.

Instead of making life easier for new immigrants — assuming this is a goal — such a law would likely just bar them from even more opportunities. Performed with ease or clumsiness, awareness or not, guile or good faith, it is none the less something that must be enacted and portrayed, something that must be realized.

If exceptions are made, that does not create a legal entitlement to additional services in that language or any language other than English. The English language shall be the official language of the United States. Official English degrades image of other languages It gives the impression that English is more important than other languages, thereby devaluing them.

Section of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of bans discrimination based "on the ground of race, color, or national origin," in "any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.

As of this writing, the efforts have not been successful. This is Alabama, they might say, we speak English. Still, elements from other dialects do exist in the standard language, which is now defined as reflecting the pronunciation of Beijing, the grammatical patterns of Mandarin dialects spoken in the northern parts of China, and the vocabulary of modern vernacular Chinese literature.

One example offered is that of Canada, with two official languages, English and French. This is a bad combination in public policy; a right that cannot be provided adequately that nevertheless adds billions of dollars in extra costs for US government and taxpayers.

To a significant degree, these were absorbed into an expanding American-ness. This would unreasonably burden government services, adding a huge layer of bureaucracy and costs.

Even then, inevitably, somebody with some obscure language will find that their "right" to have services provided to them in their own language will not be adequately fulfilled at some government facility.

Talk the talk

If imposition is to be avoided as a rule, then federal speech codes must surely qualify. Immigrants to the US who cannot or will not learn to speak English are necessarily isolated from their English-speaking fellows. But any honest appraisal of the situation in the US must concede that it simply is not.

But, it is another thing entirely for a citizen to demand these services as a right. This might even override considerations of race, as the black cultural theorist Frantz Fanon noted in his book Peau noire, masques blancspublished as Black Skin, White Masks in The Beijing dialect of Mandarin and Guangzhou dialect of Cantonese were each proposed as Should english be the national language basis for a national language for China.

Language is a national identity, to be preserved and protected, generally by the expulsion of others. They further argued that, since Ebonics was structured and spoken like any other language, its place in school texts was no more or less arbitrary than Standard English or Spanish.

He is a regular contributor at the Religion Dispatches blog. No official language is mentioned or contemplated in the Constitution. Such thinking feeds directly into a more basic question of US identity: Language is an organic force, and difficult to control. No provision is made, however, for non-English-speaking French-Canadians in Maine or Vermont, or Yiddish-speaking Hasidic Jews in Brooklyn, who are white and thus presumed to be able to learn English without difficulty.

It starts by mentioning an effort by John Adams, into establish an official academy devoted to English, a move which was rejected at the time as undemocratic.

Does official English advance the former or later? During successive imperial dynasties, the spoken language of the capital city served as the official spoken language and was used across the country by government officials who traveled to communicate with one another. Englishthe following states have existing official language laws on their books: English counter that English-only laws generally have exceptions for public safety and health needs.

Dismissing the idea that language was a threat to unity, he concluded: While being absorbed, however, they maintained traces of their ancestry. The Government of the United States shall preserve and enhance the role of English as the official language of the United States of America.

Muslims who got Pakistan made Urdu their official language and Indians made Hindi with Devanagiri script as their official language. If the English language were under threat, matters might be different.

Also introduced in the th Congress was this text from H. Eric Miller is assistant professor in communication studies at Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania.May 19,  · WASHINGTON, May 18 — The Senate voted on Thursday to designate English as the national language.

In a charged debate, Republican backers of the proposal, which was added to the Senate's. The ACLU, which is part of a group opposed to establishing a national official language, has published a paper detailing reasons that such a move should be opposed.

It starts by mentioning an effort by John Adams, into establish an official academy devoted to English, a move which was rejected at the time as undemocratic.

English is, after the Chinese one, the language most people speak and it is the most popular second language and foreign language pupils learn in school.

Why English should be the official language of the United States

The English language is often named as a “killer language” that wipes out smaller languages. National Security; Regulation. Defense; Make English our official language.

found that 88 percent of respondents believe that English should be declared the official language of the United. A push for English to be the official language of the US has both a dark history and a regressive vision for the future Why would the USA make English an official language?

| Aeon Essays It’s our 6th birthday! Explore the pros and cons of the debate Should English be the national language of India?

Download
Should english be the national language
Rated 5/5 based on 19 review